Sunday, August 02, 2015

Comprehensive investigation of voter impersonation finds 31 credible incidents out of one billion ballots cast

By Justin Levitt August 6, 2014, WashPost

Note: This is a guest post by Justin Levitt, a professor at the Loyola University Law School and an expert in constitutional law and the law of democracy, with a particular focus on election administration and redistricting.

Voter ID laws are back in the news once again, with two new opinions from the Wisconsin Supreme Court late last week dealing with the state's ID requirement, which would allow people to vote only if they provide certain forms of government-issued ID. The Court made some minor changes to the law but otherwise upheld it. However, the ID requirement is still on hold pending a federal lawsuit.

Part of this litigation — and any rational debate about the issue generally — hinges on two things: costs and benefits. The costs of these sorts of laws vary, because the laws themselves differ from state to state (some are far more burdensome than others). The ostensible benefits, though, are all the same. And in addressing these purported benefits, the Wisconsin Supreme Court blew it. Twice.

First, the court cited the idea that ID laws could enhance public confidence--that is, in theory, the laws might make us feel better about elections in that they might provide some security theater. It turns out, though, that this effect is hard to spot. People in states with more restrictive ID laws don’t generally feel better about their elections than people in more permissive states. People who think elections are being stolen, and people who think they’re not, each hold on to that opinion no matter what the governing ID rules in their area. The factor that really influences whether people think the elections are fair? Whether their preferred candidates win.

(More here.)


Blogger K-Man said...

And that means the odds of someone being struck by lightening are about 150 times greater than their chance of committing voter fraud.

Which begs the question, why on Earth are Republican legislatures and governors so psychotically obsessed with passing voter ID laws?

I think you know the answer . . .

10:52 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home