Too many checkups?
A Check on Physicals
By JANE E. BRODY, NYT
"Go Beyond Your Father's Annual Physical. Live Longer, Feel Better"
This sales pitch for the Princeton Longevity Center's "comprehensive exam" promises, for $5,300, to take "your health beyond the annual physical." But it is far from certain whether this all-day checkup, and others less inclusive, make a meaningful difference to health or merely provide reassurance to the worried well.
Among physicians, researchers and insurers, there is an ongoing debate as to whether regular checkups really reduce the chances of becoming seriously ill or dying of an illness that would have been treatable had it been detected sooner.
No one questions the importance of regular exams for well babies, children and pregnant women, and the protective value of specific exams, like a Pap smear for sexually active women and a colonoscopy for people over 50. But arguments against the annual physical for all adults have been fueled by a growing number of studies that failed to find a medical benefit.
Some experts note that when something seemingly abnormal is picked up during a routine exam, the result is psychological distress for the patient, further testing that may do more harm than good, and increased medical expenses.
(More here.)
By JANE E. BRODY, NYT
"Go Beyond Your Father's Annual Physical. Live Longer, Feel Better"
This sales pitch for the Princeton Longevity Center's "comprehensive exam" promises, for $5,300, to take "your health beyond the annual physical." But it is far from certain whether this all-day checkup, and others less inclusive, make a meaningful difference to health or merely provide reassurance to the worried well.
Among physicians, researchers and insurers, there is an ongoing debate as to whether regular checkups really reduce the chances of becoming seriously ill or dying of an illness that would have been treatable had it been detected sooner.
No one questions the importance of regular exams for well babies, children and pregnant women, and the protective value of specific exams, like a Pap smear for sexually active women and a colonoscopy for people over 50. But arguments against the annual physical for all adults have been fueled by a growing number of studies that failed to find a medical benefit.
Some experts note that when something seemingly abnormal is picked up during a routine exam, the result is psychological distress for the patient, further testing that may do more harm than good, and increased medical expenses.
(More here.)
Powered by Blogger
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home