Progressive Ponderings: On the Ground in Madison, Part 1
Teachable Moments
by Joe Mayer
Feb. 21, 2011
70,000, 80,000, 100,000 – We’re not sure of the size of the crowd at the State Capital in Madison this past Saturday, but the enthusiasm of those gathered was contagious. Elaine and I were intrigued by the creativity of the signs and the diversity of the crowds – young, prime-of-life, old like ourselves, laborers, retired, students, teachers, professionals, firefighters, police (on and off duty), in state, out of state.... We were joined by family members during the day.
Yes, the Tea Partiers came, many bused in, courtesy of the Koch brothers who had contributed $100,000 to Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker’s campaign. Many of their signs took aim at the 14 Wisconsin Democratic Senators who fled the state to deny the Republicans a quorum necessary for a vote. Of course, the democrats are being accused of thwarting democracy. These Tea Partiers and conservatives are the same people who, for the past two years, encouraged and highly approved the Republicans in the U.S. Senate who filibustered and put secret holds on both legislation and Obama nominees for administrative positions and judges.
This is not Scott Walker’s first shot at middle class public employees. As the Milwaukee County Executive he gave double digit percentage pay increases to his executives and used decreasing revenue as an excuse to lay off many lower level union employees. Walker is best described as “point man” for the Koch brothers. He mimics the Republicans on the federal level by using a fiscal crisis – caused by wealthy and corporate class entitlements – to push deficit austerity cuts onto the middle and poorer classes.
Walker CREATED the fiscal crisis in Wisconsin for the current year. He insists that Wisconsin has a $130 million deficit but neglects to mention that one of his first acts as governor was to reward his corporate sponsors by giving them $140 million in tax breaks, many of the recipients being multinational corporations.
Walker’s true intention of using the deficit as a political tool is revealed by his exempting police, firefighters, and state patrol from collective bargaining restrictions. The unions for these middle class workers supported Walker in the recent election. Fortunately, many of them understand that they will be the target tomorrow as Walker serves the corporate class today.
Wages and benefits that Wisconsin public employees earn are 4.8% LESS than private sector employees doing similar jobs, according to the Economic Policy Institute.
This issue is not about wages and benefits for public employee workers. It’s about power, power purchased by wealthy campaign contributions, power exerted by lobbyists to purchase legislation, power derived through corporate think tanks framing issues to deceive citizens into voting against their own economic self-interest, power to corrupt both our governmental and economic systems.
On Saturday we guessed that the Tea Partiers and the pro-Walker counter-protesters were outnumbered about 20 to 1. We didn’t encounter any violence but we did hear a few passionate debates. A friend, though, took a different approach in talking with a Tea Partier who was incensed about paying taxes for exorbitant wages to lazy government employees. She calmly suggested that he was there because unions had pushed for a 40 hour, five day week, that the real issue was collective bargaining, not the budget crisis. He asked what she meant by collective bargaining.
Madison is a teachable moment.
by Joe Mayer
Feb. 21, 2011
70,000, 80,000, 100,000 – We’re not sure of the size of the crowd at the State Capital in Madison this past Saturday, but the enthusiasm of those gathered was contagious. Elaine and I were intrigued by the creativity of the signs and the diversity of the crowds – young, prime-of-life, old like ourselves, laborers, retired, students, teachers, professionals, firefighters, police (on and off duty), in state, out of state.... We were joined by family members during the day.
Yes, the Tea Partiers came, many bused in, courtesy of the Koch brothers who had contributed $100,000 to Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker’s campaign. Many of their signs took aim at the 14 Wisconsin Democratic Senators who fled the state to deny the Republicans a quorum necessary for a vote. Of course, the democrats are being accused of thwarting democracy. These Tea Partiers and conservatives are the same people who, for the past two years, encouraged and highly approved the Republicans in the U.S. Senate who filibustered and put secret holds on both legislation and Obama nominees for administrative positions and judges.
This is not Scott Walker’s first shot at middle class public employees. As the Milwaukee County Executive he gave double digit percentage pay increases to his executives and used decreasing revenue as an excuse to lay off many lower level union employees. Walker is best described as “point man” for the Koch brothers. He mimics the Republicans on the federal level by using a fiscal crisis – caused by wealthy and corporate class entitlements – to push deficit austerity cuts onto the middle and poorer classes.
Walker CREATED the fiscal crisis in Wisconsin for the current year. He insists that Wisconsin has a $130 million deficit but neglects to mention that one of his first acts as governor was to reward his corporate sponsors by giving them $140 million in tax breaks, many of the recipients being multinational corporations.
Walker’s true intention of using the deficit as a political tool is revealed by his exempting police, firefighters, and state patrol from collective bargaining restrictions. The unions for these middle class workers supported Walker in the recent election. Fortunately, many of them understand that they will be the target tomorrow as Walker serves the corporate class today.
Wages and benefits that Wisconsin public employees earn are 4.8% LESS than private sector employees doing similar jobs, according to the Economic Policy Institute.
This issue is not about wages and benefits for public employee workers. It’s about power, power purchased by wealthy campaign contributions, power exerted by lobbyists to purchase legislation, power derived through corporate think tanks framing issues to deceive citizens into voting against their own economic self-interest, power to corrupt both our governmental and economic systems.
On Saturday we guessed that the Tea Partiers and the pro-Walker counter-protesters were outnumbered about 20 to 1. We didn’t encounter any violence but we did hear a few passionate debates. A friend, though, took a different approach in talking with a Tea Partier who was incensed about paying taxes for exorbitant wages to lazy government employees. She calmly suggested that he was there because unions had pushed for a 40 hour, five day week, that the real issue was collective bargaining, not the budget crisis. He asked what she meant by collective bargaining.
Madison is a teachable moment.
3 Comments:
Joe is correct in that power is important. In this case the taxpayers are taking back the power from unions.
To challenge power, “cannibal” voters must be educated as to what is happening here. The person who asked “what’s collective bargaining” is an example of a “cannibal” voter … hence they devour their own kind … if they vote, they vote not necessarily in their own personal best interests, but instead out of fear what the future may bring … for example, they fear that Obama will raise taxes, yet most people do not realize that twice he has reduced income taxes for a vast majority of taxpayers … better to vote for the one that promises to cut taxes even though they don’t realize that their slice of the tax cut pie is smaller than others. I would think that even Wisconsin businesses will soon begin to realize that they too are being played. Walker’s first act was to waive business taxes for new business based in Wisconsin … sounds similar to Pawlenty’s JOBZ program … which just pitted existing businesses against new competitors but without any restrictions. He’s pushing privatization which can only lead to cronyism … his new Wisconsin Economic Development Corp is one example of private business getting into work previously done by the state’s Commerce Department. Worse yet is his plan for the sale of state-owned heating, cooling and power plants:
"16.896 Sale or contractual operation of state−owned heating, cooling, and power plants. (1) Notwithstanding ss. 13.48 (14) (am) and 16.705 (1), the department may sell any state−owned heating, cooling, and power plant or may contract with a private entity for the operation of any such plant, with or without solicitation of bids, for any amount that the department determines to be in the best interest of the state. Notwithstanding ss. 196.49 and 196.80, no approval or certification of the public service commission is necessary for a public utility to purchase, or contract for the operation of, such a plant, and any such purchase is considered to be in the public interest and to comply with the criteria for certification of a project under s. 196.49 (3) (b)."
Hopefully, voters will wake-up to the real agenda … Walker is being opportunistic … framing a crisis to take action … let’s remember that Wisconsin is actually in pretty good financial position as the root cause of the problems are two big obligations : the Minnesota-Wisconsin tax-reciprocity delayed payment and $200 million court order to return to a medical malpractice fund after an illegal fund transfer in 2007 but that monies do not necessarily have to be paid this fiscal year.
But Walker is painting the issue as “overpaid government employees with gold-plated benefits” … and he is winning. A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey finds that 48% of Likely U.S. voters agree more with Walker in his dispute with union workers. Thirty-eight percent (38%) agree more with the unionized public employees, while 14% are undecided.
To the worker out of a job – or the person who has worked at multiple jobs without pension benefits – or the young worker just starting a new career – they look at their personal situation and see that no one is helping them, but they feel they are paying for these “gold-plated benefits” of government workers … so the “cannibal” voter devours their own kind without realizing that this could be them … this could be the first step in altering the Social Security program.
What I have not heard in Minnesota is that the Federal Government through the stimulus program helped the states last year ... but this year, the Feds are not sending monies to the states but instead reducing the payroll tax ... why doesn't Minnesota just impliment a sur-tax to reflect the payroll tax cut at the Federal level ... the net effect would be no change to the employee's take home pay and the state could avert the problem for this year.
If anyone thinks the protestors are just grass roots supporters, think again. All of the travel has been paid for by the unions, the DNC and Organizing For America. You can look it up.
And, I just love the recent narrative about Madison - that the walker supporters are just a bunch of robot dumbasses with tinfoil cones on their heads awaiting their marching orders from the Koch brothers and the Walker himself is merely a bought-and-paid-for appendage of the Koch brothers. It is a naked and feeble attempt to marginalize the support for Walker and I'm not surprised one bit this narrative.
By the way, did you know that the Koch Brothers secretly sent telepathic messages to the voters last November resulting in nearly 700 Democrats being fired at all levels of government across the country? Yeah, Ed Schultz said so, so you know it MUST be true!!
There must be millions of unsuspecting Americans who just get up and do the bidding of the Koch brothers. It's amazing the power and reach the Koch Brothers have. They make Team Obama look like a ragtag bunch of college ages hippies who haven't showered in months.
The left love to find a Straw Man and trumpet the narrative on tv, radio and the blogosphere - if it's not Glen Beck, then it's the Koch Brothers, if it's not the Koch brothers, it's Fox News, if it's not Fox News, then it's Rush Limbaugh, if it's not Rush Limbaugh, then it's Tea Party Patriots, if it's not Tea Party Partiots then it's name-your-favorite straw man.
Do you really think people are so fucking stupid that they couldn't figure out the carnage that Obama has unleashed on this country in the last two years? Have you even bothered to ask Senator Franken, Senator Klobuchar or Rep Walz if they have even read any of the recent Democrat legislation? I called their offices and their staff members said 'i think so, yes' to my question on whether or not they read the frigging bills. Senator Kerry readily admittted he didn't even bother to read the stimulus bill or the ObamaCare bill! I mean, really, who has time to read 3000 page bills where there are TV appearances to make blasting the Tea Party or Glen Beck or the Kich Brothers or a fundraiser to attend?
So, please keep up the narrative about the Koch Brothers. It only damages your credibility further. No one knows who the Kock Brothers are and are not influenced by them. Those of us not under their influence know the difference and have seen the absolute carnage of unchecked liberalism with Obama and the Democrats in the last two years and all the largesse they have handed their constituencies at the expense of the rest of us.
So, Mr Mayer, who speaks for the 2000 people that MedTronic announced today are going to be laid off this year? Who speaks for the millions out of work that can't find a job anywhere? Who speaks for the millions in the private sector who have had their 401(k) wiped out by the recession? Who speaks for the millions whose houses are now underwater thanks to government policies subsidizing housing? The public employees in this country have no clue - NONE - at how good they have it. I for one and sick of their whining and bitching about it when they have it better than just about anyone in the middle class. And I support Walker and I hope he drills those public employees in to the ground and makes them live the rest of us who bust our asses in the private sector for years without raises and having to pay more and more for our health care and have our retirement accounts wiped out and pay in to a broken social secutiry system money that we will never, get back.
I'll would love to see a Progressive Pondering speak to these issues, but I won't hold my breath for you to talk about the carnage those of us in the private sector have had to endure.
Post a Comment
<< Home